Date-stamped : 18 Nov97 - 10:29 17-21 November 1997 Pakistan v West Indies, 1st Test - Reports Day 1 - Dawn Mushtaq mesmerises Windies with his crafty bowling By Samiul Hasan PESHAWAR, Nov 17: Spin wizard Mushtaq Ahmad bowled Pakistan into a commanding position in the first Test of the three-match series against the West Indies that started at the Arbab Niaz Stadium here on Monday. Mushtaq captured five wickets for 35 runs to help Pakistan skittle out the tourists for a mere 151 - their fourth lowest score against Pakistan in 32 Tests. But the West Indies struck back through their skipper Courtney Walsh who dismissed Aamir Sohail shortly before bad light forced an early closure by 16.3 overs. Pakistan, at stumps, were 14 for one. Saeed Anwar (10) and Ijaz Ahmad will resume the home team's first innings on Tuesday morning. Mushtaq, playing his first match for Pakistan in two weeks after skipping the four-nation tournament, bowled intelligently and impressively to collect his first five-wicket haul against the West Indies and eighth in 32 Tests. "The wicket gave some assistance but I am glad that I bowled where I should have been bowling," Mushtaq said, admitting: "I was not very sure before the start of the match if I would be effective because I was short of match practice. I had started bowling only three days back since I wanted to give the troubled knee as much rest as possible." Mushtaq anticipated that the wicket would go slower and flatter as the match would progress. "But this is quite an encouraging performance and I would like to improve it in the second innings." Mushtaq came in to bowl in ideal conditions - the West Indies three down for 16 runs and the ball only 16 overs old. And he was immediately in the business when he got a lucky leg before decision against Sherwin Campbell, a stroke before lunch. After lunch, Mushtaq first bowled Phil Simmons with a wrong 'un and then invited Carl Hooper for a sweep shot to force an error as the in-form batsman was caught at silly-mid-on by Mohammad Wasim. Rawl Lewis, lost his stumps off a Mushtaq flipper. It was at this point that the West Indies headed for a disasterous start in the Test series being 58 for seven. But some erratic bowling, determined batting and the absence of Waqar Younis allowed the visitors to reach 151. Mushtaq completed the five-wicket haul in the fourth over of his second spell when he trapped Curtly Ambrose in front of the wickets. Mushtaq's first spell read: 14-7-18-4. Akram, who was lucky to lose the toss in the morning, persisted with either himself or Azhar Mahmood or Shahid Nazir from the far end and including himself tried to generate pace from an unfavourable track to be hit all over the ground. Arshad Khan, who became Pakistan's 149th Test player and fifth this season in four Tests, was used only for four overs. Need not to mention that he was brought in place of Saqlain Mushtaq who has 46 wickets in 12 Tests. The three bowlers shared 15 overs amongst between themselves in the second spell and only Azhar Mahmood succeeded by picking up the wickets of David Williams and Ian Bishop who shared in a face-saying 48-run partnership for the eighth wicket in 70 minutes. Had Pakistan gone in with Waqar Younis, the speed merchant would have been able to cause more problems to the West Indies with his trademark reverse swings. But while Azhar Mahmood picked up two wickets later in the innings, Shahid Nazir justified his selection by accounting for Stuart Williams (4) and Shivnarine Chanderpaul (0) to provide Pakistan the perfect platform to dismiss the West Indies cheaply. But the most crucial and key wicket of Brian Lara was grabbed by Wasim Akram himself when he dragged the master batsman into the shot to have him caught by Mushtaq at gully. Akram bowled with fire and venom in his first spell of seven overs. He looked determined to prove his critics and specially the chief executive of the cricket board, Majid Khan, that he has not passed his prime. Akram could easily have Stuart Williams on the first ball of the match but Said Shah, standing in his first Test, turned down a very close leg before appeal. As far as the West Indies batting is concerned, it remained lacklustre and unimpressive except for a few glorious drives played by the stylish Carl Hooper. The top order looked somewhat in a hurry and threw their bats at everything, the dismissals of Williams and Simmons are cases in point. In fact, the lower order batsmen batted with more patience and courage with the last six batsmen contributing 94 runs but most importantly occupying the crease for more than 120 minutes. Williams scored a defiant 99-minute 31 with three boundaries, Ian Bishop contributed a useful 20 and Curtly Ambrose hammered three fours and two sixes in his rapid 45-ball 30. But the way the lower order has batted, it has clearly shown that the wicket is getting easier and slower. The Pakistan batsmen should bat sensibly and cautiously to build up a good score and help the team take a big lead that would surely bring the visitors under pressure. Source:: Dawn (http://dawn.com/) Day 1 : Electronic Telegraph West Indies in anguish after batting failure By Peter Deeley in Peshawar IN THE context of their halcyon years, this was a pygmy performance by the front-line West Indies batsmen, saved from complete ignominy only by tail-end resistance. Caribbean greats of recent memory must be squirming in anguish after the opening day of this first Test and one was there to witness it. Clive Lloyd, now the manager, looked as if he had swallowed a couple of the worst offenders at lunch when four wickets - including Brian Lara - were down for 29 runs. With Lara and Shivnarine Chanderpaul dismissed for a collective three runs having faced 15 balls between them, there seems no meat to the rest of West Indies batting anymore. Such reading must put a spring in the step of Michael Atherton as he contemplates the coming Caribbean series. Courtney Walsh chose to bat then found the ball swinging considerably early on. Bowled out for 151 in 259 minutes, it was only the addition of 93 by the last three partnerships that prevented the visitors plumbing the utter depths. As it was, they avoided, by some distance, their previous lowest total in Pakistan, 53 at Faisalabad in 1986-87. There was some let up in the Caribbean gloom when Walsh had Aamir Sohail caught low at first slip by Lara to leave Pakistan 14 for one as bad light descended at 4.08 pm. The West Indies felt hard done-by that umpire David Shepherd considered conditions were too dangerous with Curtly Ambrose midway through his third over but they should direct their complaints to the Pakistan Cricket Board. To the mark the 50th anniversary of independence, the PCB have crammed two three-Test tours and a week of day-night internationals into 10 weeks. It is now winter and up here in the north of the country, the light goes so quickly that this Test is limited to 5.5 hours daily playing time and 83 overs - on paper, that is. Dew, this time in the morning, then cloud cover meant there were only 65. Pakistan called back one of their limitless supply of young fast bowlers, Shahid Nazir, 19, and he dismissed Stuart Williams and Chanderpaul in the space of three balls. Then Pakistan captain Wasim Akram angled one wider and slightly slower across Lara and the batsman, going for a full-blooded cover drive, was caught low down at gully by Mushtaq Ahmed. Wasim had remembered how Australia's Glenn McGrath dismissed Lara this way several times. Mushtaq, at his chirpy best after a fortnight off, enjoyed himself as Phil Simmons and debutant Rawl Lewis totally misread his googly. Carl Hooper was caught off his glove sweeping and Sherwin Campbell went back on his stumps to the last ball before lunch. Mushtaq's first 14-over spell gave him four for 18. Diminutive wicketkeeper David Williams battled for more than 90 minutes after being dropped early and was top scorer with 31. He shared the innings' biggest stand, 48, with Ian Bishop and at the end, Ambrose hit two sixes before becoming Mushtaq's final victim and part of his eighth five-wicket Test haul. "We bowled well and now it's up to the batsmen to help us gain a good lead," said Pakistan coach Haroon Rasheed. Source :: Electronic Telegraph (http://www.telegraph.co.uk) Day 2 report- Electronic Telegraph Missiles fly as Pakistan consolidate advantage By Peter Deeley in Peshawar THE West Indies must have thought they were fighting on two fronts yesterday in the first Test at Peshawar. Pakistan grabbed the upper hand without ever really dominating, but the visitors also had to watch their backs in the field to dodge missiles thrown by the crowd. After the West Indies' demoralising batting on the first day, Pakistan opened a 95-run lead by the end of the second day at 246 for five. On a pitch that had flattened out considerably Curtly Ambrose bowled tightly all day without result, but then blotted his copybook at the end, throwing down the ball in disgust when umpire David Shepherd ruled the light was too bad for him to bowl the day's last three balls. Fielding at third man, Ambrose was one of the targets used by spectators to lob ripe fruit - and even, it seemed, the skull of a small animal - over the high iron fencing. Play was twice stopped as the players gathered in the middle and police, waving their long lathi sticks, ineffectually chased youths up and down the terraces. When one youth was caught, he was given an impromptu kick and a clout before being carted away for goodness knows what further punishment. Home umpire Said Shah came over to the mob and appealed for calm. Then a loudspeaker announcement told the crowd in Pushto, the local dialect, that they were damaging the international image of Pakistan by their behaviour. Almost every international match held in Peshawar has produced this pelting of players by the largely Pathan people, who dwell in this rather wild frontier area close to the Khyber Pass. Philo Wallace, who was bombarded as he took water to one of his colleagues, said: "What worries me is that they will start throwing stones. We have complained to the match officials and they have taken it up with the authorities, who seem unable to do anything." The West Indies had enough playing troubles to concern them in the morning when the delicate touch of Saeed Anwar - who will surely delight Derbyshire watchers next summer - and the bludgeon of Ijaz Ahmed added 133 for the second wicket, both reaching half-centuries. It seemed at times there were two captains on the field. Phil Simmons was called into the attack by Courtney Walsh, but when Walsh left the field briefly, Brian Lara took Simmons off and replaced him with leg-spinner Rawl Lewis. Walsh simply gave Simmons a consoling pat on the back when he returned. Then, when Lara was briefing Ian Bishop on field placings, Walsh wandered up as if to see what was going on. Those close to the West Indies say they are one side divided in two - and this may be the root of their problem. Walsh took two wickets, but has been suffering from flu and did not look fully fit. He dropped a sitter of a chance at mid-on and near the end incurred four overthrows from a wild shy. Lewis, on his Test debut, hardly bothered Pakistan. His 19 overs cost 70 runs and he beat the bat once, when a top-spinner flew high off Mohammad Wasim's bat for four. Carl Hooper collected two wickets. Anwar tried to cut him and top-edged to David Williams, and then Wasim Akram was drawn out of his crease in an attempt to mow the ball to the fence and Williams took the stumping. Akram is due to fly to England next week for what he called a routine check-up on the shoulder that required an operation in August. He should be available for the second Test, starting in Rawalpindi on Nov 29. Source :: Electronic Telegraph (http://www.telegraph.co.uk) Day 2 Report - Dawn WI snatch back initiative from Pakistan By Samiul Hasan PESHAWAR, Nov 18: Pakistan squandered a golden opportunity to build a sizable lead over the West Indies when they finished the second day of the first cricket Test at 246 for five at the Arbab Niaz Stadium here on Tuesday. Last evening's overnight pair of Saeed Anwar and Ijaz Ahmad had set a perfect stage for a huge first innings total when they shared in an enterprising 133-run second wicket partnership. But the departure of the two batsmen in a space of 14 balls, exposed Pakistan's brittle and suspected batting. Mohammad Wasim was unfortunate to drag in Courtney Walsh's delivery, which kept low, on to his stumps while skipper Wasim Akram was stumped by David Williams off Carl Hooper when he was half way down the wicket What is more upsetting and mind-boggling is the fact that Akram once again came ahead of Azhar Mahmood. Akram had done the same in the quadrangular tournament that cost Pakistan the match against South Africa. It is time that Pakistan coach Haroon Rasheed injected into Akram's mind that technically Azhar is a more technically sound and reliable batsman than him. The home team could have been in further disarray had Courtney Walsh held on to simplest of chances offered by Inzamamul Haq at mid-on. But the West Indies skipper showed greasy palms and Pakistan escaped from being four down for 159. Nevertheless, Walsh partly settled his account with Inzamam when his yorker struck Inzamam's centre finger of the right foot which forced the batsman to retire. But this catch will certainly haunt Walsh in his dreams because it would have brought the West Indies right back into the Test. Pakistan coach Haroon Rasheed said Inzamam was under tremendous pain but has survived any fractures. He was optimistic that the batsman will bat on Wednesday. However, ever-reliable Moin Khan and hero of the first Test against South Africa, Azhar Mahmood, guided Pakistan safely to stumps without damage. Moin, who is aggressive by nature, struck six boundaries and a massive six to Test debutant Rawl Lewis to be batting on 36. Azhar was on 14 with the two having added 39 runs for the unbroken sixth wicket partnership. The feature of the day was, however, innings of contrasting styles by Saeed Anwar and Ijaz Ahmad. While Saeed batted with a mixture of defence and controlled aggression, Ijaz was more over ambitious when he threw his bat against everything. But the hallmark of both the innings was that the two key batsmen found their lost forms. Saeed Anwar desperately needed runs to retain his place in the side and he obliged his fans with a delight 65 helped with nine exquisite boundaries. Anwar, who recorded his 14th half century in 25 tests, was under severe pressure when he could score only 40 runs in five innings against South Africa. Anwar, like the way he scored a century against the West Indies in quadrangular cup match, played in the V with all his shots going into the range of mid-wicket and cover. Anwar's trademark flick and off the hips shots were a treat to watch as well. The way Anwar batted proved that the batsman has worked really hard on his batting as well as concentration. Ijaz Ahmad, always low starter in the beginning of his innings, was no exception this time also when nine of his first 13 runs came from edges, including two boundaries. But as Ijaz spent time in the centre, he grew from strength to strength to play some exhilarating cuts and pulls. Ijaz was extremely severe against Test debutant Rawl Lewis when he struck the bowler for four boundaries in his as many overs before lunch. Courtney Walsh never brought Lewis again until Ijaz was at the crease. But when Ijaz was well set for his sixth Test century, a shot for which he deserves a kick in the pants, brought his dismissal. He flashed a wide ball from Ian Bishop to be held by Carl Hooper in slips. Ijaz scored 65 with 10 blistering boundaries from 134 balls after a little over three hours of occupancy of the wicket. It was his 10th half century in 40 Tests. The West Indies bowling remained erratic while the fielding sloppy as the fielders gifted the batsmen with some cheap runs Courtney Walsh added the wicket of Mohammad Wasim to his yesterday's scalp of Aamir Sohail to finish with two for 30. Hooper accounted for Saeed Anwar behind the wickets and then had Wasim Akram to end with two for 37. Source:: Dawn (http://dawn.com/) Day 3: Electronic Telegraph Lara nurses West Indies rescue hope By Peter Deeley in Peshawar BRIAN LARA today faces one of the major challenges of his remarkable career if he is to dig West Indies out of trouble in the first Test against Pakistan. The task is formidable. West Indies, trailing by 230 on the first innings, are now 99 for two with two days to play. Yet there were hints from Lara yesterday that he was ready in mind and body to take up the burden. After nearly 10 hours in the field West Indies looked extremely tired when they faced a final two hours at the crease, and they lost two early wickets. With the evening shadows already creeping across the ground Lara offered a trailer of what West Indies hope will be another feature-length Test innings. He used his feet to the debutant off-spinner Arshad Khan to loft him for three boundaries in four balls, then when Mushtaq took over, spanked him for three more all through the covers. The left hander finished the day unbeaten on 36 off 44 balls having hit, in all, eight boundaries. But he was not done. While his partner Shirwin Campbell walked off, Lara summoned local bowling and stayed on the edge of the ground for another 15 minutes hammering the advertising boards. There was good reason for West Indies bowlers at least to look so weary. They let a hobbling Inzamam-ul-Haq pilot his tail-enders to such effect that the last two wickets added 77. Inzamam returned at the first wicket down, having retired the previous day with a bruised left foot, struck when he was fielding. His attack on new West Indies leg-spinner Rawl Lewis was pitiless, striking him for two straight sixes. Lewis has had a baptism he will not forget, finishing wicketless for 93 runs off 24 overs. He might have claimed Inzamam on 88 when an edge looped over slip, where Phil Simmons raced back eight paces and could not hold on. Courtney Walsh finished with five wickets in a Test innings for the 14th time, and he said he could not remember a more tiring day. Source :: Electronic Telegraph (http://www.telegraph.co.uk) Day 3- Dawn Pakistan well placed after Inzamam's heroics By Samiul Hasan PESHAWAR, Nov 19: Inzamamul Haq was denied of a personal landmark but his heroics were enough to put Pakistan in a winning position against the West Indies in the first cricket Test being played here at the Arbab Niaz Stadium. Inzamam scored a brave and courageous unbeaten 92 to propel Pakistan to 381 that provided the home team a first innings lead of 230. In the post-tea session, Wasim Akram and Mushtaq Ahmed picked up the wickets of Stuart Williams (3) and Shivnarine Chanderpaul (14) respectively to reduce the West Indies to 99 for two at stumps on the third day, still 131 runs in arrears. But the only concern in the Pakistan camp would be the form shown by Brian Lara in his 40-minute innings in which he hammered nine punishing boundaries, including two each in Arshad Khan and Mushtaq Ahmed's one over. With Lara was Sherwin Campbell batting on 34 that included five hits to the fence. But the star of the day was, however, Inzamamul Haq who was robbed of his first century at home as he ran out of partners. Shahid Nazir (18) and Mushtaq Ahmed (4) gave excellent support to Inzamam but their efforts could not help Inzamam to break the jinx. It has been the third time that Inzamam has reached 90s - second time on this centre in two years - in home Tests but failed to complete centuries. Inzamam batted with authority and confidence but the key element of luck also favoured him. He was dropped four times when on 5, 32, 35 and 88 besides escaping with a very close run-out call. Nevertheless, as people say `fortunes favour the brave', same happened to the star batsman. Inzamam was handicapped when he had to bat with a runner after receiving telling blows on his left foot. On the first day, a David Williams struck him on his ankle and on Tuesday, a Courtney Walsh yorker crushed his middle finger of the same foot. But he defied all pains to play an innings which may well help Pakistan notch up his first Test win over the West Indies in seven years. Pakistan last beat the Caribbeans in the 1990-91 home series at Karachi by eight wickets. Inzamam was a class by himself. He struck the ball with ferocious power and the nine boundaries that came of his willow hardly allowed the fielders any chance. The two sixes he struck off Rawl Lewis were simply blistering as one of them landed in the Pakistan team dressing room. Overall, Inzamam occupied the crease for four hours and 33 minutes during which he received 191 balls. But while Inzamam was dropped four times, Mohammad Wasim did all his leg work as he did the duty of the 27-year-old batsman's runner. On Tuesday, Aamir Sohail had done the similar work before Inzamam had to retire when 13. Inzamam also benefited from the legs of Wasim on 88 when he narrowly survived a run-out. Had Inzamam being running himself, he would have surely been run-out by half the pitch as he is one of the slowest movers in cricket today and perhaps the worst runners between the wickets. Inzamam's cause was also eased out by erratic and ill-planned West Indies bowlers. Inzamam was having problems in coming on to the front foot and instead of pitching the ball up, they bowled short of length which Inzamam played comfortably on the back foot with all the weight of his body coming on his strong right leg. Inzamam, on Wednesday, was quick to get down to business when overnight batsman Azhar Mahmood departed in the second over of the day with Pakistan only adding four runs to his overnight score of 246 for five. Together with Moin Khan, Inzamam added 44 runs for the seventh wicket. The stand was broken when Moin mistimed a hook and was taken safely this time by Courtney Walsh at mid-on off Ian Bishop. Moin, who had resumed this morning at 36, registered his seventh Test half century in 30 games by hitting a valuable 58 which was Pakistan innings fourth half century. The Pakistan wicketkeeper, who played the four-nation cup at Lahore as a batsman, struck seven elegant boundaries and two sixes in his 124-ball innings which lasted for about three hours. But it were the stands with Shahid Nazir and Mushtaq Ahmed that helped Pakistan reach 381 and Inzamam 92. For the ninth wicket, Inzamam and Nazir put on 43 runs in 77 minutes. And when Mushtaq joined his pal, Inzamam was 62 but managed to add another 30 in a partnership of 34 in 42 minutes. For the West Indies, Courtney Walsh, who ended Mushtaq's resilience with a perfectly executed yorker, finished with five wickets for 78 runs in 32 overs. It was the 14th time that the 35-year-old Jamaican had taken five or more wickets in an innings in 94 Tests. An injury-prone Ian Bishop finished with three for 76 and the other two wickets went to Carl Hooper. Source:: Dawn (http://dawn.com/) Day 4 report- Electronic Telegraph Lara typifies sad state of West Indies By Peter Deeley in Peshawar BRIAN LARA failed to deliver and West Indies' batting crumbled once more yesterday on a pitch without any real terrors as the one-time unofficial world champions went down sorrily to their heaviest defeat by Pakistan - an innings and 19 runs - in under three and a half days in the first Test here. You would need a long memory to recall such an insipid performance by a Caribbean XI. If the bowling was adequate - and no more - the batting lacked character, heart and quality. Quite what West Indies do to turn this three-Test series around defies conjecture. The batsmen in reserve are Philo Wallace, the new boy, and Roland Holder, now almost 30 and whose average in seven Tests is around 32. Jimmy Adams is away in South Africa leading the A team. West Indies now meet Pakistan a week tomorrow in Rawalpindi and before then there is a three-day game in Hyderabad. Sherwin Campbell was the only player in either innings to pass 50 and he had to play a lone hand once Lara was dismissed in the third over. Lara was once more guilty of flirting in the gully area as early as the second ball he faced. Wasim Akram had every right to look outraged as Mushtaq Ahmed spilt a chance coming at chest height before the batsman had even added to his overnight total. But as television showed that Wasim was guilty of a blatant no-ball, missed by the local umpire, Said Shah, it was perhaps fortunate for the sake of harmony that Lara survived. He scampered a run from that let-off but at the other end, Azhar Mahmood immediately brought a ball back into the left-hander and this time there was no argument. Carl Hooper hit Mushtaq for six but in the next over stretched for a drive and was brilliantly caught low down by the substitute Saqlain Mushtaq at short extra cover. From then on, there was almost an air of embarrassment at the procession to and from the pavilion. First the all-rounder Phil Simmons (who has scored two runs and bowled two overs in the game) tried to swing Mushtaq through the onside and the edge flew to extra cover. Campbell's stout fight ended after nearly four hours when he pushed across the line at Wasim and, next ball, Rawl Lewis (four runs and no wickets) obligingly stepped into the Pakistan captain's firing line. Five wickets had gone down by lunch and though David Williams again resisted for over an hour, it was all over 45 minutes later. Mushtaq finished with 10 wickets in a Test for the third time. He was frantically searching for one more when Courtney Walsh hit him for six. Then Wasim stole the moment in the next over as Pakistan successfully claimed their fifth leg-before in the innings - seven in the match - against Ian Bishop. West Indies' bowlers did not win a single lbw appeal but Walsh knows the penalties for speaking out about umpiring and contented himself afterwards with saying: "Much as I would love to comment I will have to leave it alone." He at least had some small consolation. Someone stole his bat but it was handed back to him after apparently being found in a house some 50 miles away. That apart, West Indies can draw no shred of comfort from this miserable defeat. Even the high fives are low threes these days. Source :: Electronic Telegraph (http://www.telegraph.co.uk) Day 4 Report- Dawn Pakistan whip West Indies by an innings and 19 runs By Samiul Hasan PESHAWAR, Nov 20: Pakistan's champion spinner Mushtaq Ahmed recorded his fourth 10-wicket haul in a match as Pakistan whipped the West Indies by an innings and 19 runs in the opening Test of the three-match series at the Arbab Niaz Stadium here on Thursday. Mushtaq, named Man-of-the-Match, followed up his five for 35 in the first innings with five for 71 in the second as the visitors were sent crashing out for 211 while needing 230 to make the home team bat again. That gave the little Mushy his career-best match figures of 10 for 106 eclipsing the previous best of 10 for 143 against New Zealand at Lahore last year. The West Indies, who lost with more than one-and-a-half day to spare, had resumed this morning at 99 for two. The match was also a personal achievement for skipper Wasim Akram. The star allrounder made his critics bite the dust by claiming four wickets for 65 runs besides becoming the only Pakistani captain after late Abdul Hafeez Kardar to beat the once mighty West Indies by an innings margin. Kardar's team had defeated F.C.M Alexander's West Indies by an innings and one run at Port-of-Spain in the inaugural 1957-58 series. Akram, leading Pakistan in a Test after more than 12 months because of shoulder injury, had come into the match with a lot of pressure. PCB's Chief Executive Majid Khan had joined the band-wagon of critics. The former Pakistan captain had lashed out at the speedster by saying he was past his prime. But Akram again proved that he still had a lot to offer to Pakistan cricket. Akram was also an integral part of the team which beat Sri Lanka by an innings at the Arbab Niaz Stadium two years ago. He had a match haul of 10 wickets in that game which was interestingly the debut Test of the centre. The last and decisive wicket, however, went to Azhar Mahmood who trapped master batsman Brian Lara in front of the wickets in the fourth over of the penultimate day. An over before, Lara was dropped by Mushtaq Ahmed at gully off Akram. Lara, who lasted just four balls today, was let off on the second ball he faced. Lara was one of the four batsmen, including top scorer Sherwin Campbell (66), to be adjudged leg before by the 57-year-old English umpire David Shepherd. Mushtaq Ahmed, by taking 10 wickets for 106 in the match, has confirmed his status as the most glittering wrist-spinner who adores the modern game. In the last 14 Tests for Pakistan, Mushtaq has captured 97 wickets starting from the 1995-96 season in which he bagged 28 wickets in three Tests, including 18 in the two Tests against Australia and 10 wickets for 171 runs in the one-off Test against New Zealand at Christchurch. Mushtaq, who is one of the five Wisden cricketers of the year, in the current Test clinched success from mesmerising spin, accuracy and bounce with deceptive googlies. His instincts were to outwit the batsmen rather than wear them down. And his positive approach worked wonders as Carl Hooper (23) attempted a cover drive to be smartly caught at covers by Wasim Akram. Then Mushtaq deceived Phil Simmons (1) with a flipper as the batsman ended up skying the ball into the hands of substitute fielder Saqlain Mushtaq. After lunch, Mushtaq had a lucky bat and pad decision against David Williams (20) while completing his five-wicket haul when Curtly Ambrose became too adventurous and danced down the track to leave substitute wicketkeeper Mohammad Wasim with a simple stumping. On Wednesday, Mushtaq had Shivnarine Chanderpaul who was caught in the slips by Ijaz Ahmed after the ball had deflected the shoulder of Aamir Sohail who was keeping wickets. Wasim Akram, whose all four victims were trapped leg before, bowled with hostility and fire. He proved that he was superbly fit by bowling 23 overs in three spells. The West Indies vulnerability against quality spinner and lack of depth in batting was clearly exposed. After Brian Lara was the third batsman out in the fourth over of the day to make the tourists 102 for three, the remaining seven wickets went down for just 109 runs. Clive Lloyd, the West Indies manager, may emphasise that his team doesn't depend only on Lara, the fact is the other way round. Moreover, except for Carl Hooper there is no batsman in the West Indies team who could easily walk into any of the top three current Test teams viz Australia, South Africa and Pakistan. There was Philo Wallace who showed form and maturity in the four-dayer at Rawalpindi but he was not included in the Test side for reasons unknown. The stand of umpiring, it would not be out of context to say, remained below-par. Said Shah, who was standing in his debut Test, and David Shepherd were too generous towards the home team but if the West Indies go back and evaluate the Test, they would find that lacklustre batting in the first innings and sloppy fielding in Pakistan's 381 combined to end in a humiliating defeat. Source:: Dawn (http://dawn.com/) Contributed by The Management (help@cricinfo.com)