Cricinfo - The home of cricket
  Cricinfo Home   Magazine  
Cricinfo Magazine RSS feed
Regulars | The List >>

Sydney's little niche in history

We turn the spotlight on the highest innings totals in Test defeats


Travis Basevi and George Binoy

January 9, 2008



Sachin Tendulkar's century pushed India's total in the second innings of the match to 532, but India still lost © Getty Images

The Sydney Test has blown up into a cricket war with the spirit of the game being questioned, but the List isn't interested in poor umpiring and accusations of racism. We've looked at the game - one which had centurions on each of the five days - and noticed that India lost despite making 532, a sizeable score by any standard, in their first innings. So our theme this week is teams that have scored the most runs in each innings of a Test they went on to lose. The Indian effort at the SCG ranks fourth among the highest totals in the second innings of such matches.

The top two second-innings totals in defeats - and five out of the top ten - were also scored against Australia. Pakistan replied to Australia's 441 for 5 at the MCG in 1972 with 574 for 8 in their first innings. Then Paul Sheahan and John Benaud scored hundreds in the second innings to set the visitors a target of 293 with five and a half hours remaining on the final day. Pakistan lasted only 57.5 overs, and were dismissed for 200, giving Australia a 2-0 lead in the three Test series with an hour to spare.

A more impressive Australian fight-back, however, came at the SSC in Colombo in 1992, where Sri Lanka went past 500 for the first time, after 37 Tests, to secure a massive first-innings lead of 291. A gritty batting performance - all the Australian batsmen reached double figures, and four scored half-centuries - helped wipe out the deficit for the loss of five wickets and set a target of 181. Chances of an Australian victory, however, looked highly unlikely when Aravinda de Silva struck 37 off 32 balls to lead Sri Lanka to 127 for 2 in the run-chase. However, his dismissal triggered a collapse and Sri Lanka lost their last eight wickets for 37 runs and fell 16 short of the target. They had to wait another seven years before they beat Australia for the first time in a Test.

Most runs in the 2nd match innings of a lost match
Team Score Opposition Margin Ground Season Scorecard
Pakistan 574/8d v Australia 92 runs Melbourne 1972/73 Test 705
Sri Lanka 547/8d v Australia 16 runs Colombo (SSC) 1992 Test 1194
Pakistan 538 v England 167 runs Leeds 2006 Test 1813
India 532 v Australia 122 runs Sydney 2007/08 Test 1857
South Africa 506 v Australia 89 runs Melbourne 1910/11 Test 112
Pakistan 504 v England 0 refused The Oval 2006 Test 1814
England 479 v Australia 81 runs Melbourne 1924/25 Test 159
Australia 465 v South Africa 38 runs Adelaide 1910/11 Test 113
India 454 v England 247 runs Lord's 1990 Test 1148
India 449 v Pakistan 168 runs Bangalore 2004/05 Test 1743
England 447 v Australia 119 runs Adelaide 1920/21 Test 137
England 435 v West Indies 231 runs The Oval 1976 Test 781
England 432 v Australia inns & 25 runs The Oval 2001 Test 1558
England 430 v Australia 210 runs Leeds 1989 Test 1121
South Africa 419 v England 77 runs Johannesburg 2004/05 Test 1734
England 419/9d v South Africa 71 runs Nottingham 1951 Test 334
Australia 419 v India 59 runs Melbourne 1980/81 Test 895
Australia 419 v England 106 runs Adelaide 1994/95 Test 1284
England 418 v Pakistan 22 runs Multan 2005/06 Test 1770
West Indies 416 v England 210 runs Lord's 2004 Test 1707

Click here for lowest second-innings totals in a Test win.

The Adelaide Oval has been the stage of the two highest first-innings totals in Test defeats. In 2003-04, Australia piled up 556 at the breakneck run-rate of 4.37 an over and gained a slender lead of 33 after Rahul Dravid's 233 led India to 523. A collapse in Australia's second innings - Ajit Agarkar claimed 6 for 41 - left India with 230 to chase, which they accomplished with four wickets in hand. In 2006-07 it was Australia who fought back after conceding 551 to England in the first innings. Even though England had a first-innings lead of 38, their choke in the second, for 129, left Australia with an easy 168 to chase.

Most runs in the 1st match innings of a lost match
Team Score Opposition Margin Ground Season Scorecard
Australia 586 v England 10 runs Sydney 1894/95 Test 42
Australia 556 v India 4 wickets Adelaide 2003/04 Test 1673
England 551/6d v Australia 6 wickets Adelaide 2006/07 Test 1819
West Indies 526/7d v England 7 wickets Port of Spain 1967/68 Test 635
Australia 520 v South Africa 6 wickets Melbourne 1952/53 Test 365
England 519 v Australia 5 wickets Melbourne 1928/29 Test 180
England 496 v Australia 7 wickets Leeds 1948 Test 302
Australia 490 v West Indies 1 wickets Bridgetown 1998/99 Test 1453
South Africa 484 v England 9 wickets The Oval 2003 Test 1659
South Africa 451/9d v Australia 8 wickets Sydney 2005/06 Test 1780
West Indies 448 v Sri Lanka 10 wickets Galle 2001/02 Test 1567
Australia 447 v England 6 wickets Leeds 2001 Test 1556
Australia 445 v India 171 runs Kolkata 2000/01 Test 1535
England 445 v Sri Lanka 10 wickets The Oval 1998 Test 1423
Australia 435 v England 8 wickets Sydney 1932/33 Test 224
New Zealand 433 v Australia 9 wickets Christchurch 2004/05 Test 1739
Australia 429 v West Indies 10 wickets Bridgetown 1983/84 Test 986
Bangladesh 427 v Australia 3 wickets Fatullah 2005/06 Test 1797
England 425 v Australia 7 wickets Lord's 1930 Test 195
India 424 v Australia 8 wickets Bangalore 1997/98 Test 1413

Click here for lowest first-innings totals in a Test win.

The largest third-innings total in a losing cause was scored at Headingley in 1967, after India had conceded so much ground to England in the first innings that the gap was too large to bridge. Geoffrey Boycott was dropped after this Test, though he scored 246 off 555 balls out of England's 550 for 4, because, as Wisden reported, of his "lack of enterprise". India were asked to follow on after they were dismissed for 164 and even though MAK Pataudi's 148 led India's fightback, their 510 in the second innings set England a target of only 125.

Most runs in the 3rd match innings of a lost match
Team Score Opposition Margin Ground Season Scorecard
India 510 v England 6 wickets Leeds 1967 Test 618
Australia 485 v England 5 wickets Sydney 1903/04 Test 78
Australia 477 v England 9 wickets Birmingham 1997 Test 1368
Australia 476 v England 7 wickets Adelaide 1911/12 Test 118
South Africa 473 v Australia 4 wickets Cape Town 2001/02 Test 1593
India 465 v Pakistan 8 wickets Lahore 1978/79 Test 832
South Africa 452 v Australia 10 wickets Sydney 2001/02 Test 1582
England 441 v Australia 8 wickets Nottingham 1948 Test 299
West Indies 439 v Australia 3 wickets Georgetown 1977/78 Test 822
England 436 v West Indies 10 wickets Nottingham 1950 Test 325
South Africa 434 v Sri Lanka inns & 153 runs Colombo (SSC) 2006 Test 1810
India 422 v West Indies 7 wickets Port of Spain 1961/62 Test 528
Australia 417 v West Indies 3 wickets St John's 2002/03 Test 1645
England 417 v South Africa inns & 92 runs Lord's 2003 Test 1653
New Zealand 413 v England 9 wickets Birmingham 1965 Test 591
India 412 v England 9 wickets Chennai 1984/85 Test 1008
Australia 408 v England 9 wickets Sydney 1897/98 Test 53
Sri Lanka 406 v Pakistan 6 wickets Karachi 2004/05 Test 1719
South Africa 401 v Australia 7 wickets Sydney 1910/11 Test 115
West Indies 398 v Australia 9 wickets Georgetown 2002/03 Test 1638

Click here for lowest third-innings totals in a Test win.

Nathan Astle's spectacular 222 off 168 balls, the fastest double-century in Tests, led New Zealand to 451 in the final innings against England in Christchurch in 2002, the highest fourth-innings total in a Test loss. New Zealand were chasing 550 and Astle added 118 runs with Chris Cairns, who was batting at No. 11 because of an injury, to take New Zealand from 333 for 9 to within 98 runs of victory, before he was dismissed.

Most runs in the 4th match innings of a lost match
Team Score Opposition Margin Ground Season Scorecard
New Zealand 451 v England 98 runs Christchurch 2001/02 Test 1594
India 445 v Australia 47 runs Adelaide 1977/78 Test 816
New Zealand 440 v England 38 runs Nottingham 1973 Test 722
England 417 v Australia 45 runs Melbourne 1976/77 Test 800
England 411 v Australia 193 runs Sydney 1924/25 Test 158
Sri Lanka 410 v Australia 96 runs Hobart 2007/08 Test 1847
Australia 402 v England 103 runs Manchester 1981 Test 907
India 397 v England 170 runs Lord's 2002 Test 1610
West Indies 394 v England 60 runs Manchester 2007 Test 1835
India 376 v England 171 runs Manchester 1959 Test 477
England 370 v Australia 119 runs Adelaide 1920/21 Test 137
England 370 v Australia 277 runs Brisbane 2006/07 Test 1817
England 363 v Australia 11 runs Adelaide 1924/25 Test 160
India 355 v Australia 39 runs Brisbane 1967/68 Test 626
West Indies 352 v Australia 382 runs Sydney 1968/69 Test 646
England 350 v Australia 206 runs Perth 2006/07 Test 1821
Sri Lanka 348 v Australia 173 runs Hobart 1989/90 Test 1133
New Zealand 345 v England 165 runs Nottingham 1983 Test 960
Australia 339 v South Africa 38 runs Adelaide 1910/11 Test 113
Australia 336 v England 12 runs Adelaide 1928/29 Test 179

Click here for lowest fourth-innings totals in a Test win.

If there's a particular List that you would like to see, email us with your comments and suggestions.

Travis Basevi is the man who built Statsguru. George Binoy is an editorial assistant on Cricinfo

 
Post this story on your favourite website Email this page to a friend Print this page Feedback
Current fantasy: SL v India, England v SA & County Cricket
Login to check standings
    Add a Cricinfo Widget to your website now!
Cricinfo Widgets
    Live scores, results, news, features and more - a click away
Download the Cricinfo Toolbar
Related Links More by this Writer About this Writer

Latest Features Latest News


Sponsored Links
Check out all the action only on Tour Diaries
Brought to you by Airtel
Bright Moments
Brought to you by Philips
Gatorade Pacers 2008
Register Now
Follow the new 2008/09 Premier League season
On ESPNsoccernet

Cricinfo Products
Steve Waugh talks on cricket at the Olympics
Watch on Cricinfo.tv
Add a Cricinfo Widget to your website now
Portable apps for your site


 
Top 5 player searches
Most read stories